The crumbling IS ‘caliphate’ in Syria

The IS’s headquarters in Tabqa at the western gateway to Raqqah has been crushed like a sand castle by American bombs. At a dam complex on the Euphrates River where IS until May was torturing prisoners, all that’s left of the extremists are militant slogans scrawled on the wall and a pile of trash.
It’s far too soon to say that life is returning to normal here after liberation, but much of the horror is over. Mines and improvised explosive devices were cleared here last week. Young children flash ‘V’ for victory signs. Beards have nearly disappeared. The only people sporting bushy beards on Thursday were American special operations soldiers who accompanied visiting US special envoy Brett McGurk.
The city is strewn with rubble, and Ahmad Al Ahmad, the co-president of the newly formed Tabqa Civil Council, described it as a ‘city of ghosts,’ with perhaps 40 percent of its buildings damaged. The electricity, water-distribution and school systems have been largely destroyed. Young boys who were indoctrinated at IS training camps are trying to find their balance in a new world where beheadings and the chanting of slogans are over.
To look at people’s wary faces, uncertain but with a trace of hope in their eyes, it’s like they’re waking up from a nightmare. The newly formed town council is meeting, created by the Kurdish-led military force that cleared the town, and it seems to be getting cooperation from local Arabs. A new internal security force is policing the streets and occasionally pops off warning fire. At a warehouse near the town center, the first shipment of American food arrived on Wednesday; sacks of flour and rice are stacked on pallets, ready for distribution, and much more is coming in the next week, says veteran US relief coordinator Al Dwyer.
A boisterous group of young Syrian men is gathered outside a tire and auto-parts shop across from the warehouse. American military advisers aren’t sure at first that it’s safe to talk with them, but the men press eagerly toward two visiting reporters. Abdul-Qadr Khalil, 22, dressed in a bright blue-nylon jacket, speaks for the group. He complains that there’s not enough food, water, gas or bread, and there are no jobs. But he dismisses the idea that IS will ever take hold here again.
“No, never!” says Khalil, and the young men around him nod in unison. “It will be impossible to live if they come back. They will kill all of us.” Nothing is permanent in this shattered country, but there are tipping points when the momentum shifts, and this seems to be one. As the battle for Raqqah begins in earnest, this city offers a preview of what’s ahead:
 The black balloon of the IS caliphate is deflating quickly in Syria, as in Iraq. There may be up to a year of hard fighting left, but the surprise for US officials is that the battle in eastern Syria is going faster and better than expected. In a symbol of that advance, Kurdish commanders gave McGurk the ring of an IS emir who once used it to seal orders to kill Tabqa’s inhabitants. The emir blew himself up when he was surrounded, leaving behind the ring and its now-empty claim of authority.
 The confrontation with Syria and Russia that led to the shoot-down of a Syrian fighter jet just south of here two weeks ago seems to have passed, at least for now. Despite the Russians’ public protests, they quietly agreed last weekend on a roughly 80-mile ‘deconfliction’ line that stretches from a few miles west of here to a village on the Euphrates called Karama. That line appears to be holding, and it’s a promising sign that broader U.S.-Russian cooperation in Syria may be possible.
 The Kurdish-led militia known as the Syrian Democratic Forces has shown it can defeat IS, so long as it’s backed by US air power. The Tabqa battle in May was perhaps the most ambitious and daring operation of the war so far. Five hundred SDF soldiers were airlifted across Lake Assad in V-22 Osprey helicopters in a raid that caught IS by surprise. The SDF suffered about 100 killed and more than 300 wounded in the bloody operation, but it worked, and in this part of the world, success breeds success. Arab refugees are now streaming toward the Kurdish-led SDF, rather than away, and 8,200 US-trained Arab forces are joining the front lines.
Lt. Gen. Stephen Townsend, who commands US and coalition forces in Syria and Iraq, explains in an interview that the Kurdish military leadership here is “the thickener, the hardener you put on the glue to make it hold.” McGurk repeats at every meeting with local officials that the U.S.’s ability to fix Syria is limited. America can help defeat IS, and it can provide quick stabilization support to repair water, electricity and other infrastructure. But it can’t do everything.
This sense of what’s achievable for the US in Syria with its limited commitment, and what isn’t, is probably the biggest takeaway from our visit here. The US seems to have found a way, in its almost accidental alliance with the Syrian Kurds, to drive IS from eastern Syria and stabilize this part of the country. But US officials frankly admit they don’t have the resources or a clear strategy to repair Syria as a whole. The rubric seems to be: Do what you can with the forces available, and don’t promise more than you can deliver.
“This is not a work of beauty. This is pragmatism,” says Maj. Gen. Rupert Jones, the British deputy commander of coalition forces in Iraq and Syria who accompanied McGurk here. The US and its partners are supplying potent special operations forces for training and air support. But the Syrian Kurds and their Arab allies are doing the fighting on the ground, and for better or worse, it’s their vision of governance that will take hold as IS flees.

— Washington Post Writers Group

David R. Ignatius is an American journalist and novelist. He is an associate editor and columnist for The Washington Post. He also co-hosts PostGlobal, an online discussion of international issues
at Washingtonpost.com, with Fareed
Zakaria